Difference between revisions of "Talk:Where To Play"

From PinWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (Slight edits to my comment (mostly formatting improvements).)
(Describing the changes I just made to the page to make it less US centric.)
 
Line 2: Line 2:
  
 
# Create multiple versions of this page: USA & World, or North America, South America, Europe, Africa, etc. (This might require this page to become a Disambiguation page.)
 
# Create multiple versions of this page: USA & World, or North America, South America, Europe, Africa, etc. (This might require this page to become a Disambiguation page.)
# Keep everything on the existing page, and create new top level sections for each Country. I am going to try to implement this method, and if the page grows too large then we can split it up later.
+
# Keep everything on the existing page, and create new top level sections for each Country (or Geographic Area).
  
[[User:BrianHanifin|BrianHanifin]] 17:56, 11 October 2011 (BST)Brian Hanifin
+
I decided to go with option #2 to start. I separated these into two separate commits in case you disagree with my 2nd revision.
 +
#Added '''Canada''' and '''United States''' as 2nd level headings and bumped the States/Provinces to 3rd level headings.
 +
#With an eye on ''usability'' improvements I removed the empty States headings.
 +
 
 +
My reasoning for the 2nd edit is that it is trivial for an editor to add a new State header, however it is frustrating to a user to click on a State only to find it hasn't been filled in yet.
 +
 
 +
[[User:BrianHanifin|BrianHanifin]]

Latest revision as of 12:34, 11 October 2011

EZL brought up a good point (and this bothered me a little bit when I edited the page). This page is US centric. I think there are two ways we can go about this.

  1. Create multiple versions of this page: USA & World, or North America, South America, Europe, Africa, etc. (This might require this page to become a Disambiguation page.)
  2. Keep everything on the existing page, and create new top level sections for each Country (or Geographic Area).

I decided to go with option #2 to start. I separated these into two separate commits in case you disagree with my 2nd revision.

  1. Added Canada and United States as 2nd level headings and bumped the States/Provinces to 3rd level headings.
  2. With an eye on usability improvements I removed the empty States headings.

My reasoning for the 2nd edit is that it is trivial for an editor to add a new State header, however it is frustrating to a user to click on a State only to find it hasn't been filled in yet.

BrianHanifin